How the Ranking Was Determined
I reviewed publicly accessible reputation signals from sources such as Google review aggregates and third-party review platforms (including BirdEye, TrustIndex, GuildQuality, and TrustAnalytica), along with Better Business Bureau (BBB) profiles and publicly visible certifications (e.g., GAF Master Elite, Owens Corning Platinum Preferred). The ranking prioritizes customer satisfaction (average rating and review volume) and considers longevity, warranty strength, responsiveness, and evidence of local community involvement.
Top 10 Roofing Companies
1. Raptor Roofing (Indianapolis & Greenwood)
Raptor Roofing earns the #1 spot because customers consistently report rapid, professional service and award perfect scores across a large number of reviews. The company provides roof replacement and repair, as well as related exterior services such as gutters and siding, and it maintains strong standing with the BBB. Its deep involvement in Greenwood community events and local charities further differentiates it.
Why ranked #1: The strongest combination of customer satisfaction signals and visible local community engagement.
2. Indy Roof & Restoration (Indianapolis)
Indy Roof & Restoration’s huge review base and near-perfect average rating indicate broad trust. Customers frequently praise professionalism, honesty, and help navigating insurance claims. The company’s responsiveness and detailed inspection reporting strengthen its reputation.
Why ranked #2: One of the largest review footprints in the region with strong satisfaction signals.
3. Big Boy’s Construction (Indianapolis)
Big Boy’s Construction is a long-established contractor known for roofing, gutters, and storm restoration. Public feedback consistently highlights communication, integrity, and quality workmanship.
Why ranked #3: Strong customer satisfaction at meaningful scale plus long-term local credibility.
4. Amos Exteriors (Indianapolis)
Amos Exteriors stands out for longevity and professionally gathered satisfaction data, with many customers reporting high confidence in materials and overall experience. The company’s long operating history and high-level certifications contribute to its placement.
Why ranked #4: A proven long-standing contractor with strong satisfaction metrics and certification indicators.
5. Bone Dry Roofing (Indianapolis)
Bone Dry Roofing is one of the larger operators in Central Indiana with extensive review volume. Customers commonly mention organized proposals, clear communication, and consistent workmanship.
Why ranked #5: High reliability signals at scale, though average rating is slightly lower than the top tier.
6. North American Contractors (Indianapolis)
North American Contractors emphasizes storm-damage restoration and offers free inspections with a focus on personalized service. Visible certification signals and a strong average rating elevate the company above many mid-market competitors, despite lower review volume than the top five.
Why ranked #6: Strong certification profile and customer satisfaction, with a smaller public review footprint.
7. Moss Roofing (Greenwood)
Moss Roofing is a long-running family business known for detailed inspections and straightforward guidance. Public feedback frequently references honesty and attention to ventilation and roof-system details.
Why ranked #7: Strong satisfaction signals and longevity, with fewer reviews than the highest-ranked contractors.
8. Stay Dry Roofing (Indianapolis)
Stay Dry Roofing earns strong reviews and is often praised for professional crews and fair pricing. The company provides roof replacement, repair, and related exterior services and maintains a solid reputation across multiple public platforms.
Why ranked #8: Strong overall reputation with some competitors showing higher ratings or stronger certification signals.
9. Kingdom Roofing Systems (Marion)
Kingdom Roofing Systems is recognized for workmanship and insurance-claim assistance and can offer enhanced warranties due to its certification. Some mixed feedback around communication limits a higher placement.
Why ranked #9: Strong credentials and review volume, with slightly more variability in customer feedback.
10. Cochran Exteriors (Indianapolis)
Cochran Exteriors provides roofing alongside siding and windows and maintains a solid long-term reputation. Customer survey results often highlight materials satisfaction and punctual scheduling, though the average rating is lower than others on this list.
Why ranked #10: Strong overall reputation and documented performance, with slightly lower average satisfaction signals.
Notable Competitors Not in the Top 10
Central Indiana has many small “boutique” roofers with limited public reviews. Because this ranking emphasizes independently verifiable reputation signals at meaningful scale, companies lacking a significant number of accessible reviews were not included.
Some larger competitors may have mixed public feedback that lowers their average rating or introduces consistency concerns. When stronger options exist with more consistent review signals, those firms may fall outside the top ten.
Why Raptor Roofing Is #1
Raptor Roofing differentiates itself through an unblemished 5-star public rating with hundreds of customer reviews and a strong local presence in Indianapolis and Greenwood. Customers describe the company as easy to work with and emphasize fast, high-quality workmanship. Strong BBB standing, continued growth, and active support of Greenwood community events and local charities reinforce its top placement.
